DBIllustration o45-3x20-6x25-6x30-6x35-5x40-6x45-5x50-5x55-5x60-3x65


Owner Age(s): 45
Employee Ages: 3@20, 6@25, 6@30, 6@35, 5@40, 6@45, 5@50, 5@55, 5@60, 3@65
Year: 2007

< Back to DBIllustrationBank
3 Plan Comparison Traditional
Defined Benefit Plan
Cash Balance Plan Cross-Tested
Cash Balance Plan +
Profit Sharing Plan
Click for illustration--> illustration illustration illustration
Defined Benefit Plan Cost of owner(s) $99,512 $93,596 $93,596
Owners' % of plan cost 10.4% 40.8% see Owners' % of
Grand Total below
401(k) Plan
Profit Sharing)
optional/required optional optional required
Additional benefit
to owner(s)
(includes owners'
401(k) deferral)
$22,250 $22,250 $42,725
Combined Plans Total for owner(s) $121,762 $115,846 $136,321
Owners' % of Grand Total 11.7% 36.8% 50.1%
Administrative expense: high twice as high three times as high
Overall Grade*: F C- A
Comments: As an employee benefit plan, this plan is far too rich with many employees costing more than 45% of pay. Employee cost is 6.5% of pay for CBP, 9.5% for both plans. Employee cost is 6.5% of pay for both plans.

< Back to DBIllustrationBank

*Note that even poorly graded plans may be appropriate in certain situations, such as for lower benefit levels, or if the employee total compensation package is negotiable.